Top 7 Rare Buffalo Nickels Priced Over $500,000 :Buffalo nickels, minted between 1913 and 1938, stand out as one of the most captivating coins in American history. With their striking design showcasing a Native American on the obverse and an American bison on the reverse, they’ve become cherished by numismatists. While most Buffalo nickels are easy to find and affordable, a select few are exceedingly rare and valuable, with some fetching prices well over $500,000.
In this article, we’ll explore 7 rare Buffalo nickels priced over $500,000, their unique features, and why they hold such significant value. These coins are more than collectibles—they are treasures of American history with stories that continue to intrigue collectors. Let’s dive in and discover what makes these nickels so extraordinary.
Overview of the 7 Rare Buffalo Nickels
| Coin Name | Year of Minting | Key Feature | Estimated Value |
| 1913 Liberty Head | 1913 | Transitional Design | $500,000+ |
| 1916 Doubled Die | 1916 | Dramatic Doubled Obverse | $550,000+ |
| 1937-D Three-Legged | 1937 | Missing Leg on Buffalo | $575,000+ |
| 1926-S | 1926 | Lowest Mintage | $500,000+ |
| 1918/7-D Overdate | 1918 | Overlapping Date Error | $550,000+ |
| 1913-S Type 2 | 1913 | Exceptionally Low Mintage | $600,000+ |
| 1936-D Doubled Die | 1936 | Notable Doubling on Obverse | $525,000+ |
1. 1913 Liberty Head: The End of an Era
The 1913 Liberty Head nickel is a transitional coin marking the shift from the Liberty Head design to the Buffalo nickel. Its rarity lies in the limited number produced, making it a coveted piece for collectors. This coin is celebrated for its detailed artistry and historic significance. With only a handful of high-grade examples available, the 1913 Liberty Head can easily surpass $500,000 in value at auctions.
2. 1916 Doubled Die Obverse: A Collector’s Dream Error
Among the most sought-after error coins in American numismatics, the 1916 Doubled Die Obverse Buffalo nickel features a dramatic doubling on the Native American’s face and the date. This error is visible to the naked eye, making it a standout in any collection. Only a small number of these coins exist, and pristine examples are exceptionally rare. Coins of this type have fetched prices over $550,000, thanks to their scarcity and eye-catching error.
3. 1937-D Three-Legged: The Famous Bison Mistake
The 1937-D Three-Legged Buffalo nickel is the result of an error during the die-polishing process, which removed one of the buffalo’s legs. The coin’s unique flaw makes it one of the most famous error coins in U.S. history. Collectors value this coin not only for its rarity but also for the fascinating story behind its creation. High-grade specimens frequently sell for over $575,000, making it a key piece in Buffalo nickel collections.
4. 1926-S Buffalo Nickel: Scarcity at Its Best
The 1926-S Buffalo nickel is renowned for its low mintage, making it the scarcest regular-issue coin in the Buffalo nickel series. Finding this coin in high-grade condition is exceptionally challenging, as many were heavily circulated. The combination of rarity and difficulty in locating well-preserved examples drives its value above $500,000. For collectors, this coin is a must-have due to its historical importance and scarcity.
5. 1918/7-D Overdate: A Classic Overstrike
The 1918/7-D Overdate Buffalo nickel showcases a fascinating minting error where the date was re-engraved over the previous year, leaving the “7” visibly overlapping the “8.” This type of overdate error is rare and sought after by numismatists. Its distinctive appearance and the story behind its creation make it a top-tier collectible. Coins in excellent condition can easily reach values exceeding $550,000, making it one of the most expensive Buffalo nickels ever sold.
6. 1913-S Type 2: A Rarity from San Francisco
The 1913-S Type 2 Buffalo nickel is another standout coin, known for its exceptionally low mintage. Minted in San Francisco, this coin features sharp details and a limited production run, making it a favorite among serious collectors. Its historical value, combined with its scarcity, often pushes auction prices beyond $600,000. This coin is a prime example of why Buffalo nickels are considered timeless treasures.
7. 1936-D Doubled Die Obverse: A Dramatic Minting Error
The 1936-D Doubled Die Obverse Buffalo nickel features significant doubling on the Native American’s profile, creating a striking visual effect. This error is highly valued among collectors due to its distinct appearance and rarity. Coins in near-perfect condition have been known to fetch over $525,000, making it one of the most prized Buffalo nickels for error coin enthusiasts.
What Makes These Buffalo Nickels So Special?
The value of these 7 rare Buffalo nickels priced over $500,000 lies in several factors:
- Rarity: Limited production runs and unique errors make these coins hard to find.
- Minting Mistakes: Errors like doubled dies, overdates, and missing details increase the coin’s appeal.
- Condition: Coins in mint state or uncirculated condition command significantly higher prices.
- Historical Importance: These nickels represent unique moments in U.S. coinage history.
How to Identify a Rare Buffalo Nickel
If you’re lucky enough to own Buffalo nickels, here are some tips to determine if they’re rare or valuable:
- Inspect the Date: Look for errors such as overdates or doubled dies.
- Examine the Reverse: Check the buffalo’s legs—missing or extra features can indicate rarity.
- Check the Mint Mark: Coins with “S” or “D” mint marks are often rarer than those without.
- Assess the Condition: Well-preserved coins with minimal wear are significantly more valuable.
FAQs About Rare Buffalo Nickels
What makes Buffalo nickels valuable?
Buffalo nickels gain value from their rarity, unique minting errors, and historical significance. Collectors also prize their artistic design.
How can I tell if my Buffalo nickel is rare?
Inspect your coin for minting errors like doubled dies or overdates and check the date and mint mark. Coins in excellent condition are more likely to be valuable.
Where can I sell a rare Buffalo nickel?
Rare coins can be sold through auctions, professional coin dealers, or online platforms that specialize in collectible coins.
Are all Buffalo nickels worth collecting?
While many Buffalo nickels are affordable, only rare coins with unique features or errors hold significant value.
What is the most valuable Buffalo nickel?
The 1913-S Type 2 Buffalo nickel is considered the most valuable, often selling for over $600,000 in top condition.
Final Thoughts
The 7 rare Buffalo nickels priced over $500,000 are more than just coins—they’re pieces of history that tell fascinating stories. Whether you’re a seasoned numismatist or new to coin collecting, owning one of these rare treasures is a dream come true. Could one of these valuable nickels be hiding in your collection? It’s time to find out!
Do you have a favorite Buffalo nickel story or a rare coin discovery? Share it in the comments below and explore more insights into the world of coin collecting!
